THE CONGREGATIONAL OR LIBERAL CHRISTIAN CHURCHES OF SHELBY COUNTY
By Mrs. Emily L. Douthit
THERE are only four of these congregations, and they have all been organized within the last twelve years. Their origin and history are no inseparably connected with the life of the present pastor that, in giving an account of their rise and histo
ry, some brief personal allusions may not be out of place. Jasper L. Douthit is a native of this county, and his mother was a native of the state. She was born in a fort in Franklin county, Ills., and came to this county with her father, Francis Jordan,
about the year 1828, when the Indians still roamed these prairies and lighted their campfires. His father, Andrew E. Douthit, emigrated from East Tennessee with his parents in 1832. The Regular Predestinarian Baptists, known as "Hardshell," were the pr
incipal sect in the eastern part of the county then. For the first sixteen years of his life J.L. Douthit scarcely ever heard any other kind of Gospel, excepting an occasional discourse from the Disciples, commonly called Campbellites. His mother being
a devoted Christian and member of the "Hardshell" Baptist Church, he wished to believe and live in church fellowship with her. But the more he thought upon the subject, the more he found it impossible for him to believe the doctrine; neither could he in
good conscience unite with any of the churches in the vicinity. He was beset with doubts and misgivings, and began to suspect that all sects were more or less in error. He longed for the fellowship of Christians, but felt that they imposed burdens of cr
eeds contrary to the Gospel. From his earliest recollections he was longing to find some Christian people who would receive members into their fellowship on the simple basis of a solemnly avowed purpose to be good, to get good, and do good, without subsc
ribing to any creeds that were difficult to understand or believe. This longing desire for a larger and simpler Christian fellowship, which resulted in his taking the lead in the formation of these societies, seems to have been born with him and prompted
not of his or any human will. As this longing increased, a thirst for knowledge and greater usefulness also increased, until at the age of seventeen Mr. Douthit left home to attend the Shelby Seminary. While connected with this institution he was induc
ed to unite with the Methodist Episcopal Church, though with some protest, and not fully assenting to the Articles of Faith of said church. In 1857 he was married to Miss Emily Lovell, of Abington, Mass. About the year 1860, being twenty-six years old,
and still dissatisfied with all the churches around him, and knowing no people in the world who would receive him into their fellowship on the basis he desired, he began without the sanction or authority of any body of believers, to speak out in public wh
at he believed, and to declare against slavery of body and against slavery of mind and soul.
Receiving little sympathy in his opinions, and meeting with much opposition, he yearned more than ever for a closer Christian fellowship. He accordingly, in 1861, wrote a letter to Rev. T.W. Higginson, of Worcester, Mass., who he supposed from what he ha
d read and heard of him, belonged to an independent and liberal church. Mr. Higginson responded very kindly, informing the inquirer of the existence of just such a body of people as he had been longing to meet for so many years. For further information,
Mr. Higginson referred him, among others, to Rev. Robert Collyer of the Second Unitarian Society of Chicago. Through Mr. Collyer, Mr. Douthit was led to attend the Western Unitarian Conference, held at Detroit, Mich., and there, June 22d, 1862, he was f
ormally ordained to the Christian Ministry; Revs. M.D. Conway, now of London, C.G. Ames, T.J. Mumford, Geo. W. Hosmer, D.D., Rev. Robert Collyer and others taking part in the ordination service. The newly-ordained minister, with fresh courage, returned t
o his birthplace and continued to preach in school-houses, groves, and private houses, wherever he could get a hearing. His watchwords were: Union, Liberty, Charity and Progress in Civil Government and in Religion. But the storm of civil war beat heavi
ly, and absorbed all other interests, and the Unitarian preacher made slow progress. Greatly needing a better preparation for the ministry, by the direction and assistance of generous brethren and friends, he was led to take a course of three years instr
uction in the Theological Seminary at Meadville, Pa., graduating from this school in June, 1867. After a brief ministry at Princeton, Ill., with some people to whom the Hon. Owen Lovejoy had once been pastor, Mr. Douthit could not resist the impulses to
resume his labors in the region of his birth. There was no church to extend him a call, give him welcome, or promise a salary. He had no income, and there was no assurance of support for himself and family, excepting what he might make by cultivating a
little farm, and his wife earn by teaching a subscription school. Aid had been given heretofore by Unitarian Missionary Societies, but as he had taken this step contrary to the advice and wishes of friends who had influence with these societies, he could
not now hope for further aid. However, it was not long before the American Unitarian Association of Boston, Mass., made an appropriation for his partial support, which has never been since entirely wanting.
The first preaching in 1867-8-9 was mostly at Log Church, (an old building, three and a half miles east of Shelbyville, and first erected for the use of Predestinarian Baptists) and at Salem Schoolhouse, about three miles south of Log Church, and near the
residence of Mr. Jacob Sittler. The only material aid that the preacher received the first year from those with whom he labored in the Gospel, was one big jug of sorghum molasses, and this was given by a foreigner who had been reared to the custom of su
pporting religious institutions. The Baptists who had mostly occupied this ground after the Indians left, believed that all missionary effort was of the devil, and that it was wrong to educate a man and pay him for preaching the Gospel. Of course such t
eaching was
Page 136
not without its influence on the old settlers and natives who were not Baptists. The next year, 1868, the local contributions reached about ten dollars. In this year a large Sunday-school was organized at Log Church and did good work, notwithstanding so
me bitter opposition and riotous disturbances. The Boston Sunday School Society and other friends in the East donated one hundred and fifty or more volumes of valuable books for the Sunday-school library. Some were suspicious of all books from Boston, a
nd were opposed to receiving this donation. However a public meeting was called, a vote was taken, and the books were thankfully received by a vote of forty-two to twelve, several not voting. The books were by such authors as Miss Sedgwick, Mrs. Childs,
T.S. Arthur, and Fanny Gage; and were eagerly read and did much toward improving the manners and morals of the neighborhood. Horse racing and card playing were less frequent on Sunday, and the dram shops grew less popular and began to feel the penalty o
f violating the law. The keepers and some of the customers were enraged so that the Superintendent of the Sunday-school was assaulted one Sunday while the school was in session. But it all worked together to create a greater interest in the work begun.
Elder John Ellis, a liberal preacher of the "Christians," rendered Mr. Douthit efficient service during this year.
Oak Grove Church of Liberal Christians. On Sunday, June 1st, 1868, Salem, (now Oak Grove), church of Liberal Christians was organized by the following persons making a public confession of the Christian faith, and covenanting together in church fe
llowship; namely; Jacob Sittler and his wife, Sidney; Wm. G. Buckley and his wife, Martha J.; Mr. Beverly Milligan, George W. Douthit, Jasper L. Douthit and his wife, Emily L. This first congregational church covenant was entered into at the old Salem Sc
hool-House. The weather being pleasant, and the house being too small to accommodate all present, the service was held out of doors, in the shade of an old elm tree, since cut down. Elder John Ellis preached the sermon on the occasion, and formally welc
omed the little company to the Christian brotherhood. On Monday, July 6th, 1868, a meeting was held near the Griffith graveyard about three and a half miles south-east of Shelbyville. This meeting was held in the woods on the spot where in early days a
log school-house stood. Dr. A.L. Kellar of Shelbyville and J.L. Douthit being present, stated that it was proposed to erect a house of worship there, to be held jointly for the use of Liberal Christians and "Christian," (Campbellite) congregations, said
house to be free to all other Christian people when not used by either of these two congregations. Jacob Sittler, in addition to subscribing liberally volunteered to superintend the carpenter's work. On Monday, the 16th of November, the trustees met on
the ground and decided to begin to build. A deed to the site was given by Edwin Martin. The people who could not give money had a mind to work, and the building was completed in time for dedication, September 29th, 1870. Robert Collyer, of Unity Church
, Chicago, was present, and preached an eloquent sermon, which will long be remembered by those who heard it. The first trustees of this building were Jeremiah Southers, John C. Coconower, Jacob Sittler, and J.L. Douthit.
On January 16, 1870, at a meeting held in the unfinished Oak Grove chapel, the declaration of faith, covenant and constitution of the Liberal Christian Church of Shelbyville township, Shelby county, Illinois was adopted. The following are extracts from t
he declaration and covenant:
"We believe that all duty is embraced in the following precepts of Jesus: 'All things whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them.' 'Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy str
ength, and with all they mind, and they neighbor as thyself.'***
"Our only test of fellowship shall be Christian character - 'By their fruits ye shall know them' - therefore, any one evincing an earnest purpose to lead a pure and upright life before God and man, may become a member of this church by signing its covenan
t and constitution, - 'for in every nation he that feareth God and worketh righteousness, is accepted with Him,' and shall be with us. * * *
"We covenant with one another, and we bind ourselves in the presence of God to walk together in all His ways according to the best of our knowledge and ability. * * *
"We promise to remember mercy and do justly to all, not dealing oppressingly or cruelly with any one. We resolve to be temperate in all things; diligent in business; 'fervent in spirit; serving the Lord' in our special avocations, - shunning idleness as
the bane of any people or state. We promise to give of our substance as God prospers us for the benefit of the poor and needy, and for such other purposes as have for their object the spreading of the gospel and the upbuilding of God's kingdom or righteo
usness on earth. We promise to walk with our brethren with all watchfulness and tenderness, avoiding jealousies and suspicions, censurings, provokings, secret risings of the spirit against them; but in all offences to follow the rule of our Master and to
bear and forbear, give and forgive, as He has taught us. All this we sincerely promise to try to be and to do; and while remembering that we are weak; and that to err is human, we are resolved, by the help of God, as often as we do in any way fail and fa
ll, we will arise and try again."
This covenant is mostly in the words of the covenant of the first church organized in the colony of Massachusetts Bay, at Salem, in 1629, two hundred and fifty-one years ago. That old covenant was drawn up by Rev. Francis Higginson, the pastor, who was o
ne of the first ministers ordained in New England, and the ancestor of Col. T.W. Higginson. The latter, in alluding to this covenant, calls it "Puritanism's original declaration of independence in America," and well says that "it proves the essential gre
atness of the founders of New England society that those who claim to hold the most advanced outposts of thought have got so little beyond even the letter of this covenant, and not at all beyond its spirit."
Over sixty members have entered into this church covenant at Oak Grove, but part of these have moved away, and part of them have transferred their membership to the First Congregational Church in Shelbyville.
Christian Union Church, near Mode. - In April, 1872, an attempt was made to raise funds to build a house of worship at the graveyard between Jacob Elliott's residence and the village of Mode. But the attempt failed, because by the terms of subscr
iption to the building fund, the house was to be only open to all orthodox and evangelical Christians when not used by the German Reformed Church. The people had got their eyes open to the fact that the holders of church property on such conditions claim
ed the right to exclude the Unitarians and any others whom they had a mind to judge as not orthodox. Only a small sum was subscribed on this plan, when it was abandoned and a subscription started which made the church open to all Christian people when not
used by that religious society, which should take care to keep the building in order and repair. Mr. Thaddeus Elliott most diligently solicited funds on this plan, and very soon about $1,500 was pledged. The stone foundation of the church was laid in 1
872. J.H. Worley did the stone work and John Root & Bros. the carpentering work. "Granny" Elliott, the aged wife of Jacob Elliott, with her own
Page 137
hands, generously cooked for the workmen. She has since gone to her reward. Many others lent a hand, so that the edifice, capable of seating five hundred or more persons, was neatly finished, and dedicated July 20th, 1873. Robert Collyer preached the s
ermon, and was assisted in the services by Rev. William Boone, of the M.E. Church, Mr. Robert Tyson and J.L. Douthit. In 1874 an Independent Christian congregation was organized here. The Rev. James F. Brown is identified with this congregation. He was
ordained to the Christian ministry at a Conference of the Fraternity of Liberal Religious Societies of Illinois, held in Shelbyville April, 1877, with Rev. John H. Heywood, of Louisville, Ky., presiding. Mr. Brown occasionally preaches to congregations
in the vicinity of Mode, the village of his home, though he is prevented by physical disability from very active duties. The trustees of this Christian Union Church are Jacob Elliott, Abraham Gollagher, John Warner and George Williams.
The Log Church Society. - The Log Church above mentioned, was first built for the "Hardshell" Baptists, and stood near where Thomas Dobins now lives. It was removed to the present place to make room for the Indianapolis and St. Louis railroad. I
t became the school-house for Liberty school district until the district became so populous that two school-houses were required, and then, ceasing to be used for public school purposes, by the terms of the original deed the property reverted to Mr. Thoma
s Rice. Mr. Rice was of the Roman Catholic faith, but seeing the good that the house had done, and there being no other to accommodate the religious interests of the neighborhood, he determined that it should continue to be held for that purpose. On Jan
uary 4, 1871, Mr. Rice gave a deed for the property to the following persons and their heirs forever, namely: Bayless M. Davis, Levi N. Douthit, Christian Peterson and Jasper L. Douthit; said parties of the second part to have and to hold the same in tru
st, "for the use of the religious societies of the neighborhood." A Sunday-school is kept here during part of the year, and Mr. Douthit preaches here frequently. No other religious body uses the house regularly.
The Unitarian Society of Sylvan. - During the years 1871-72, Mr. Douthit held services in the Methodist Chapel, Mt. Carmel, four miles directly south of Shelbyville. While preaching here, the nucleus was formed out of which grew the society of Un
itarian Christians, which now worships at Sylvan School-house. Joseph Reid and his wife Eliza, were the first members. The officers of this church have failed to furnish the writer with exact data. It must suffice to say that it is composed of about fi
fteen members. It supports a lively Sunday-school a part of the year, with an attendance of from fifty to seventy-five.
First Congregational (Unitarian) Church of Shelbyville. - On February 15th, 1874, regular preaching was begun by Mr. Douthit in the old court-house, Shelbyville. Several unsuccessful attempts had been made to hold services in this city. The foll
owing record occurs in the minister's diary for "Monday, Feb. 22, 1869. A muddy disagreeable ride to the court-house and back last night. About two dozen were present. They listened suspiciously rather than kindly to what was said about Liberal Christi
anity. Some acted as if they had got into the wrong pew and were ashamed of it. Next Sunday I shall try again in the day time."
Accordingly on Sunday morning, February 28, 1859, Mr. Douthit walked from his home, four and a half miles from Shelbyville court-house, to preach per appointment which was made the week before and thoroughly advertised. A short time before the hour for s
ervice, one man who had been on a drunken spree the day and night previous, and who, it was supposed, was just out of the lock-up, came and peeped in at the court-house door and inquired what was going on. When told that there would be preaching if any o
ne came to hear, he remarked "Wal, mebbe I'll be around by meetin' time," and turned away. The lonely preacher waited till nearly twelve o'clock, but this man not returning and no one else coming, he turned his steps homeward somewhat cast down but deter
mined to try again. Occasional efforts were made during the next five years that were not very successful. But now, (1874), it was determined that if the audience averaged no more than one dozen, and if the minister had to be his own janitor, and pay al
l incidental expenses, and receive no word of encouragement, he would nevertheless stick to it regularly for one year and leave results to God. At the first meeting there were about two dozen persons present, and the audiences gradually increased. Unexp
ected friends arose. A small Sunday-school was organized in the spring of 1874, and rapidly increased in numbers and interest. The Church of the Disciples, Boston, Dr. James F. Clark pastor, sent us a donation of books for the Sunday-school library. Mr
. Jacob C. Smith, of Marshall, Illinois, added interest to the mission by teaching one of his popular singing schools in the court-house, during May, 1874, closing with a jubilee concert, and giving part of the proceeds for the purchase of an organ for th
e society.
On Thursday evening, May 13, 1875, at a meeting held in the court-house, thirteen persons united in church covenant by signing