HISTORY OF METHODISM IN MOULTRIE COUNTY.
BY REV. CHRIS. GALEENER.
Methodism is one of those peculiar institutions which from their very constitutions, are enabled to live, flourish, and increase in all climes, among all nations and with all classes of people. Having within itself the means of propagation so thoroughly d
istributed that whenever one member becomes isolated from the great body, howsoever far, he does not have to await directions from the head, but with the commission of the great Master, "Go, preach the gospel unto every creature," he at once enters upon t
he work, collecting together as many as may desire to join in some kind of public worship, and either expounds to them the Word of God, or leads them in a service of prayer. Thus, in the vast majority of instances, have the seeds of Methodism been sown in
the newly settled parts of these western states. Small groups of these people meeting together at stated periods in private dwellings or school-houses, where there were any, formed the nucleus, around which, in after years, gathered large, and often weal
thy congregations. These small bands of worshipers at this early day seldom saw a minister save the local preacher, who, borne westward by the tide of emigration, came with his Bible and hymn book, preaching and singing the gospel of Christ free to all; l
iterally without money and without price. These local preachers often formed these scattered bodies into what they then called small circuits, but which in reality were much larger than our largest ones at the present day. These they supplied so fa
r as they were able with regular services at stated times, until they could be reached by the regular itinerant, when they were regularly organized into Classes and Quarterly Conferences.
Methodism in Moultrie county was no exception to the rule. Long before it was separated from Shelby county and dignified by the title it now bears, there came among the emigrants, a "goodly sprinkling" of Methodists, who settled in various parts of what i
s
Page 149
now called Moultrie county, and around them soon gathered others of the same persuasion, for they were then a social people and longed for the society of each other. As soon as they could they usually formed a society, and prosecuted the work so diligentl
y that they often grew with great rapidity. Almost the first Methodist preaching must have been by local preachers, among whom we find the following. Rev. H. M. Tremble, who resides at present (1880) near Paradise, Coles county; Rev. R. B. Ewing, George M
. Henson, of Whitley Point, and Rev. Prentice, who was a partner of Ewing's in business at one time at East Nelson. As early as 1835 all the societies in Shelby county had been organized into one grand circuit, extending from Vandalia to a point somewhere
in what is now called Douglas county. This vast district was traveled around once each month, and the preacher usually preached every day in the week except Monday. He was compelled, of course, to travel in all kinds of weather, and often forced to swim
his horse through swollen streams amid great danger. Sometimes leaving his horse tied in the woods on the bank of some mad torrent, he commended his life and soul into the hand of his Creator, after which he plunged boldly into the boiling waters with ful
l determination to meet his next engagement or die in the attempt. Gradually, however, this huge circuit was diminished until it contained in 1837 about what now lies in the bounds of Shelby and Moultrie counties, and this year we find that it was to be t
raveled by Moses Roberts, but he had not been long on the work when death interposed, and he breathed his last at the house of Charles Sawyers, at Wabash Point, Coles county. Barton W. Randle was then Presiding Elder of the district which contained the ci
rcuit, From 1839 to 1845, our information seems unreliable, as there are too conflicting statements, but during this interval the probability is that Wm. C. Brundle, Joseph H. Hopkins, and H. Buck, each traveled the circuit one year. In 1846 Sullivan circ
uit was formed from Shelbyville circuit, and Rev. C. W. C. Munsell was appointed preacher in charge, this being his first work. N. S. Bastion was at this time Presiding Elder. The circuit then contained the following preaching places, all of which were in
this county, viz: East, Jonathan, E. Grahanis, East Nelson, Julia Ann, Richard Nazworthys, Jacob McCuins, Hewitt's Grove, Ewing's Grove, and James Camfield's. Nazworthy's was probably the oldest society in the county, and had been formed years before by
Rev. R. B. Ewing, who was a local elder and preached extensively in those days in various parts of the county. Beside the appointments named in Moultrie county, there were some in Shelby, and one or two in Coles county; but at this time there was not a ch
urch edifice belonging to the Methodists in all this county. There was one, however, in the bounds of Sullivan circuit, but it was situated at Sand Creek in Shelby county, and was built of round logs with the cracks daubed with mud. There were eighteen ap
pointments and two hundred and fifty-two members in the entire circuit. Mr. Munsell's salary was fixed at two hundred and forty-five dollars; of this he realized about fifty dollars.
1847, Rev. J. H. Hopkins became pastor, N. S. Bastion, P. E. There were 334 members this year.
About this time Ewing and Prentice, who were in business at East Nelson, invoiced their goods and sold out to Thornton and Elder; their store house thus becoming vacant was bought by the society at this place as a house of worship. This was perhaps the fi
rst house of worship ever owned by the Methodists in the county, though not originally designed for that purpose. Nelson society was the most flourishing in the circuit and continued so for many years; it became the home of the preachers, and we have been
informed that at one time there was a parsonage there.
1848, C. Arnold was appointed pastor and G. W. Fairbank, P. E. who remained upon the district four years. At this date it is perhaps impossible for us to conceive the hardships that these pioneers of Methodism were called to pass. Mr. Fairbank's district
extended from Danville to Hillsboro, and he was compelled to travel over this scope of country, upon horseback, destitute as it was in many places of roads and bridges, and it is related of him that on one occasion he made the complete round of his distri
ct and, returned home, having received the sum total in cash of seventy-five cents. His good wife remained at home during these long journeys, and at one time Dr. H. Buck, then a young man stationed in Danville, visited her in the absence of Elder F. -- a
nd being desirous of learning how she fared, asked permission to look into her harder, where he found only a few bones from which almost the last vestige of meat had disappeared. "Why Mother Fairbank!" said he, This seems to be the valley of dry bones! "O
h!" said she, "There's some meat on those bones."
But Dr. Buck's sympathies were aroused, and departing from the house he soon returned with something, if not more substantial, at least more palatable than "dry bones."
1849, C. J. Tolle was appointed pastor. This year the Methodists constructed the first church they had ever built in the county. It was at Hewitt's grove about two miles northeast of Lovington, built of logs neatly hewed, and the congregation was so arist
ocratic that they had the cracks daubed with lime and sand and the walls white washed. By some this was no doubt considered a useless expense, but we see that the tastes of the people were changing. In Sullivan also this year, a new frame church was compl
eted and dedicated; it had been commenced in 1847, during the pastorate of Rev. J. H. Hopkins, but from some cause was not completed for forty years. The cost of this edifice was about one thousand dollars, and it was constructed by R. B. Wheeler. The, fi
rst board of trustees consisted of Wm. Purvis, James Elder, R. B. Ewing, James Camfield and Elijah Bridwell. The deed to the lot upon which it stands bears date June 13th, 1859, and was signed by James A. Freeland. This was the first church ever built in
Sullivan. It is now occupied by Pifer's carriage shop. In 1850, Rev. G. W. Bennett became pastor, and was succeeded in 1851 by Lewis Anderson, and he in 1852 gave place to Rev. J. H. Dolson, who only made one round of the circuit when he died; and R. B. E
wing who has been mentioned before supplied the work until the conference met in 1853, when A. Don Carles became pastor and A. Bradshaw Presiding Elder.
1854, J. W. R. Morgan was pastor, R. C. Norton P. E.
1855, J. W. Aneals was pastor. 1856, A. Buckner was pastor, and continued two years. J.S. Crane was P. E.
1858, W. H. McVey became pastor. During the decade from 1849 to 1859, but little progress was made. A gain of sixty memhers had been made in the whole circuit. No property had been acquired, and so far, we know none lost; affairs were in an easy condition
, and the church seemed to make no special efforts.
1859, I. Groves became pastor and remained two years, during which time there was a slight loss in the membership, but two new churches were projected, one at Lovington completed this year and one at Sullivan, but not completed until 1862.
In 1861, C. Y. Hecox became pastor and W. D. P. Trotter, P. E. who remained on the district four years. 1862, David Gay was appointed pastor; on coming to the work he found an unfinished church at Sullivan, which he finished the same year; it is the one o
ccupied at present by the society as a place of worship. It cost about $2,000, and was dedicated by President Cobleigh of McKendree College. The first board of trustees consisted of James Elder, S. H. Morrell
Page 150
J. R. Duncan, E. H. Hunt, A. B. Shortess, John Millizen, and William Elder. 1863, J.C. Baker was pastor; 1864, Thomas Riley, who left the work after about six months; 1865 M. W. Everhart was appointed pastor and R. W. Travis Presiding Elder, who continued
until 1867. When Mr. Everhart reached the work, he became so discouraged that after preaching once, he mounted his horse and, without informing any one of his intentions, he rode away fully resolving never to return. He went to Ohio, where he remained ab
out four months, or until February 1866, when he returned and remained until the ensuing conference appointed his successor, who was Rev. T. C. Lapham, now in business in Shelbyville, Ill. His administration was a prosperous one.
In 1867 T. C. Lapham was succeeded by Rev. J. B. Wolfe, who managed to enlist his people in the work so much that the membership increased this year from 214 to 399. This was, perhaps, the most prosperous year, spiritually, in the annals of Sullivan circ
uit. At the end of the year, Sullivan and Lovington, so long united together in the same circuit, were divided, each becoming the head of a circuit. Mr. Wolfe returned to Sullivan, and did efficient work, being succeeded in 1869 by Rev. A. Waggoner, who s
eems to have lost some ground; for he reported nearly one hundred less members than his predecessor left at the close of his last year. He was followed in 1870 by Rev. Arthur Bradshaw, who reported fifty members less than his predecessor. Rev. A. M. Pilch
er became pastor in 1871, and this year there was a decrease of thirty members. During the year a neat chapel was dedicated a few miles southeast of Sullivan, known as Graham's chapel. For the years 1872, and 1873, Rev. R. L. Robinson was pastor, and repo
rted a slight increase in membership. 1874, Rev. I. H. Aldrich was appointed pastor, but on account of his age was forced to retire, and Rev. E. A. Hamilton completed the year. 1875 Rev. B. F. Rhodes became pastor, but left the work in about six months, a
nd Rev. A. H. Rusk completed the year. 1876 and 1877, Rev. M. B. McFadden was pastor. During this time there was a revival, and several conversions were reported. 1878, Sullivan became detached from all other appointments, and Rev. E. S..Wamsley was made
pastor, in which capacity he served the charge two years, during which time no material progress was made, neither any essential loss, save the removal of a few families of influence. Altogether the.church, remained about as when be found it.. In 1880 C.
Galeener became pastor, the history of whose pastorate remains to be written by another historian.
Thus far we have traced the history of Methodism in Moultrie county, but confining our attention principally to those events which could be narrated in
connection with those relating to the society in Sullivan; but there are also good societies existing at other points in the county, and we will briefly survey the history of Lovington and Bethany.
Lovington.--The history of Lovington M. E church is almost identical with that of Sullivan until 1868, when the Sullivan circuit was divided, since which time they have employed different pastors. This society probably had its birth at Hewitt's Gr
ove in 1845, and Dr. Hiram Buck was its father. The people met at first in private houses to listen to the gospel, until 1849, when the hewn log-house which we have before described was built; this they occupied until 1858, when the edifice at present use
d was built at a cost of $2,500. The architects were A. A. & G. M. Williams, and the first board of trustees, John Foster, Alex. Porter, George Hewitt and Jacob Murphy. The following have served as pastors since 1870, soon after the circuit was divided: 1
870, N. S. Buckner; 1871 and '2, J. W. Lapham; 1873, I. N. Bundy; 1874-5, J. C. Kellar; 1876, Abner Pottle; 1877, Peter Slagle; 1878, W. A. McKinney; 1879, E. Gollagher; 1880, J. W. Warfield. The church is at present in a flourishing condition, with good
prospects of future usefulness.
Bethany.--There had been Methodist preaching at Marrowbone, in the vicinity of Bethany, at a very early day; but no permanent society seems to have been organized there. In 1860 Rev. I. Groves, who was then on Sullivan circuit, preached there; but
he seems to have failed in organizing anything of a lasting character. The first permanent organization was effected there in 1870 by, Rev. Joseph Shartzer, who remained pastor two years. In 1872 Rev. J. M. Boone became pastor, during whose term the pres
ent church there was built. It is constructed of brick, and cost $3,000. This is the only brick church owned by the denomination in this county. The first board of trustees consisted of Jacob Scheer, John A. Strain, A. H. Bliss, Daniel P. Warren and Rober
t Crowder. The following have been pastors there: 1873 and 4, D. C. Burkett; 1875, A. Y. Graham; 1876, Abner Pottle; 1874, W. P. Shoemaker; 1878 and 9, A. Y. Graham; 1880, A. H. Rusk. The church is in a flourishing condition, out of debt, and money in the
treasury.
Besides the churches mentioned, there are also the following, from which we have failed to receive any facts, though we have tried again and again, and also searched through the clerk's office for old deeds and certificates of incorporatio
n, but in vain. Summit has a respectable frame-structure; Graham and Cadwell's chapels also of frame. Further than this, we know nothing in regard to the time of organization. In conclusion we may say that Methodism is on a pretty firm basis, and intends
to do all she can in furthering the interests of Christianity in Moultrie county. She also extends the right hand of fellowship to all sister denominations, and wishes them a hearty "God-speed."
UNITED BRETHREN.There is a goodly number of this denomination scattered through out the county; but as yet no church building has been constructed for church purposes. Service is held at various school-houses in the county, where t
he members enjoy the preaching and services, as rendered by the teachers of the faith.
Page 151